The Day the Focus Died

If we failed to do this, I feared, we would stop leading the industry and turn into “merely the CSS trick of the week.”

For the past few years, I’ve been looking back at creative and business decisions I made, and wondering how wise they were. This is the story of one of those decisions.

In 2008, A List Apart, for people who make websites™ reached its tenth year of independent publishing. Looking back on ten years of the magazine’s web standards advocacy, I decided it was time to broaden out ALA’s mission. It was time, in short, to take a more holistic approach to web design, covering all the skills required to create great usable web content and applications. If we failed to do this, I feared, we would stop leading the industry and turn into “merely the CSS trick of the week”—as I phrased my concern to the ALA staff.

Here’s how I explained A List Apart’s change of direction on this very site:

For most of its decade of publication, ALA has been the leading journal of standards-based web design. Initially a lonely voice in the desert, we taught CSS layout before browsers correctly supported it, and helped The WaSP persuade browser makers to do the right thing. Once browsers’ standards support was up to snuff, we educated and excited designers and developers about standards-based design, preaching accessibility, teaching semantic markup, and helping you strategize how to sell this new way of designing websites to your clients, coworkers, and boss.

Most famously, over the years, writers for ALA have presented the design community with one amazing and powerfully useful new CSS technique after another. Initially radically new techniques that are now part of the vocabulary of all web designers include Paul Sowden’s “Alternative Styles,” Mark Newhouse’s list-based navigation, Eric Meyer’s intro to print styles, Douglas Bowman’s “Sliding Doors,” Dave Shea’s “CSS Sprites,” Dan Cederholm’s “Faux Columns,” Patrick Griffiths and Dan Webb’s “Suckerfish Dropdowns,” Drew McLellan’s “Flash Satay,” and so on and so on. There are literally too many great ones to name here. (Newcomers to standards-based design, check Erin Lynch’s “The ALA Primer Part Two: Resources For Beginners“.)

Web standards are in our DNA and will always be a core part of our editorial focus. Standards fans, never fear. We will not abandon our post. But since late 2005, we have consciously begun steering ALA back to its earliest roots as a magazine for all people who make websites—writers, architects, strategists, researchers, and yes, even marketers and clients as well as designers and developers. This means that, along with issues that focus on new methods and subtleties of markup and layout, we will also publish issues that discuss practical and sometimes theoretical aspects of user experience design, from the implications of ubiquitous computing to keeping communities civil. — A List Apart is Changing

Here’s what I thought:

As browser support for CSS continued to improve, our community could spend less time inventing and memorizing workarounds like Dave’s CSS Sprites, Dan’s Faux Columns, and so on. We needed those workarounds at the beginning of the fight for web standards support, and we still needed some of them in 2008. But the need was lessening as standards came of age, and as folks in the web design community began using CSS as a matter of course, instead of something that had to be argued for and worked around.

Behind the decision

Focusing on CSS, semantic markup, and workarounds had made sense during the early standards advocacy period, but it was time to begin turning the ship around to focus on customer research, content strategy, customer safety, and so on.

I reasoned that most of the web designers I knew were generalists, like me, who could write a little, design a little, code a little, and so on. Such readers would probably be just as interested in, say, Information Architecture and inclusive design as they had been in front-end code.

I also knew that web design was beginning to transition from a mostly freelance and small studio concern to a corporate, in-house one; with this change came increased specialization.

I wanted A List Apart to be for everyone. For folks who wrote CSS, HTML, and JavaScript, it goes without saying. But also for those curious about the web’s emerging possibilities as an applications platform, the world’s newspaper, and so on. Adding the new topics to our mix made sense to me.

It was also the principle behind Eric Meyer’s and my An Event Apart conference (RIP)—a single track, multi-day event covering everything from pixels to prose, coding to content—and beyond. That conference found its audience. Until COVID, it was a success as a curriculum and as a business.

Pushback will find you in the end

But the holistic approach was less successful on A List Apart. The nuanced argument I thought I was making (web standards will always be essential to our mix, but we need to learn other skills as well) turned off some readers and writers.

Hand to God, I even received emails from some of our magazine’s top contributors accusing me of abandoning our mission. They said they were off to write for other publications (mainly Smashing Magazine), and they were as good as their word. If I ever changed my mind about my apparently offensive decision, they said, they might consider writing for ALA again. But I should not hold my breath.

These writers’ reactions surprised me. They also hurt. And they annoyed me because I thought I’d clearly explained that adding new topics didn’t mean ending the original topic. It was like saying no to the meal because you didn’t love the dessert.

Nevertheless, there began to be a dropping-off in ALA’s sheer number of readers, as well—even though our new content also attracted new readers. Some of that drop-off had to do with purely mechanical problems, e.g. an ill-fated temporary site migration that broke our existing URLs—the ones folks had been bookmarking and recommending for a decade. And where our redirect engine somehow also failed, so that folks returning to a beloved bookmark couldn’t get there except via Search.

Look back in angora

So: Was broadening the focus a mistake? From a pure business point of view, it was. Readership declined. Readers who had devoured A List Apart entirely because of its singular focus on standards-based front-end design now became more interested in my friendly competitor’s publication. Writers who had made their names on A List Apart became associated with Smashing instead. And a new publication—CSS Tricks—soon captured much of the rest of the ALA audience. A List Apart was still read and respected, but our most hardcore readers and writers were now likely to get their CSS fix elsewhere.

This all came back to mind as I watched Geoff Graham and a small band of humans resurrect CSS Tricks this week (after the original owners sold it to a company that had no idea what to do with it other than cram it full of ads).

I respect and am delighted for Geoff Graham and his readers, and I plan to be a CSS Tricks reader myself.

So: in broadening ALA’s focus, had I done the right thing?

I would not be happy if ALA were still almost entirely focused on front-end code because my restless brain has long since moved on to other topics. So from a purely selfish creative POV, changing ALA was the right decision for me.

Besides, even with A List Apart mostly quiet these days, our community has two great places to soak up fine articles on standards-based design. And today we also have a vast range of individual blogs on which to read innovative ideas. That was not the case in 1998 when ALA launched.

I built ALA to serve a particular need. A need nobody in 1998 was meeting. That need continues to be satisfied to this day. So the community is unhurt.

And of course ALA readers who stuck with us gained knowledge across a tremendous range of important topics. Which supports my thought that it was the right educational decision to broaden our range of topics.

But as a business decision? Probably not my best. (What do you think?)

Fediverse reactions

21 responses to “The Day the Focus Died”

  1. Frederick Good Avatar
    Frederick Good

    What was the goal? If it was to help people and push things forward, it was a massive success! If the goal was to run a lucrative business forever, then maybe less so. I call it a great success, because it certainly molded, motivated, and educated me during those years. So, “success” is defined differently, depending on the goals of who you asked.

    1. L. Jeffrey Zeldman Avatar

      Thank you, Frederick!

  2. ajkandy Avatar
    ajkandy

    I think the holistic view is sorely needed now more than ever. What’s missing is an educational curriculum that teaches foundational HTML and CSS, not in isolation, but in parallel with information and cognitive science.

    I continually refer people to Scott McCloud’s “Six Steps” from Understanding Comics as a parallel to web design. It’s far too easy to get hung up on surface details (the CSS trick of the week) and forget that your site is for a broad range of differently abled people who are there to do something.

    If anything, the web’s absorption into JS frameworks never made sense to me. It was like the whole industry tilted into accommodating people who refused to learn HTML / CSS, preferring a giant workaround instead. The decades of “CSS is too hard” propaganda were never properly rebutted, IMO.

  3. Desiree Zamora Garcia Avatar

    Missing the forest for the trees, Zeldman! People needed that as a community back then. People started needing more than just tutorials and best practices, and you saw that.

    Today, people want community from community. We’re so isolated in this industry.

  4. Simon Cox Avatar
    Simon Cox

    I think you did the right thing. ALA was bang on the nail at the right time when we needed it most.

    As we are all aware the whole scene evolved over the years and we all either became more generalist or niche experts. Audiences come and go and often come back again. It feels like there is a growing momentum to go back to the authentic web and ALA sits right there, waiting patiently.

  5. bridgetstewart Avatar
    bridgetstewart

    I learned so much from ALA! Things that were not CSS or Standards related. I think I was your target audience. Gaining at least conversational knowledge about topics like copy writing, information architecture, research techniques and the like meant that I was able to have meaningful conversations with practitioners. That was important when I moved into management and needed to seek help from coworkers in other departments or seek outside assistance. It’s very difficult to know what you need if you aren’t familiar with the territory. I wouldn’t have known what questions to ask or be able to glean when someone’s reply met my (hopeful) expectations or sounded like a snake oil salesman.

    So, I am sorry if ALA’s direction seemed like a business mistake, but it certainly blessed me and I will be forever grateful. Thank you!

  6. Angela Avatar

    Longtime fan of A List Apart, as a UX researcher and IA/content strategist. To this day, I still refer to The Core Model, Seeing the Elephant, and Elements of Social Architecture.

    Even as a non-designer, ALA design articles were useful to me. I don’t even think I interpreted the change as losing focus. I thought it really stopped publishing for a while, then when it was back “on”, I couldn’t fully feel what it was about. And maybe that’s the downside for me about the broadening — that since I was used to the “old version”, it was like the content lost an “anchor” (web design technique).

    And it’s not fully the site’s doing. I also think the design/development thought leadership was very…crowded or confusing in the past 7-ish years. Probably coinciding with all the bootcamps and such.

    I actually continued to browse ALA topic pages, or revisit old pieces. I would even show university students ALA pieces and they were surprised about what it covered ~15 years ago. It would be great to hear what the newer readers think, since maybe it did end up reaching a new base.

    1. Angela Avatar

      *design/development thought leadership space…

      I don’t think it was a failure, if you as editor, really found yourself pursuing different avenues. Then you were just being true to yourself — which is a great thing in the era of monetized interests, and robo-writing.

  7. Robert Handrow Avatar

    The short version of what I want to tell you is this: thanks to the book series-which takes a broader look at how and why different disciplines should work together to ensure that websites function effectively for both customers and businesses—I was able to develop my role as a strategist at a web agency in the first place. I understand your regret about the consequences for your business, but for me and my colleagues, this holistic approach has led to a great deal of personal and professional growth. I wish the book series were still around and that the world had simply understood and appreciated your efforts better.

  8. porcupine Avatar
    porcupine

    I was someone who aspired to write for ALA, but ended up writing for SM instead. More than once. ALA was the holy grail, yet it felt as though only a select few were allowed to become authors.

    For me, the problem wasn’t about broadening the scope. It was the formality, the lack of a certain spirit, the inability to take ourselves a little less seriously. Kevin Cornell’s illustrations were genius, but what we really needed was more of that same spirit: an easy-going atmosphere that never compromised on standards.

    1. L. Jeffrey Zeldman Avatar

      You’re talking about taking a lighter editorial touch. I get it.

  9. zelDemon Avatar

    Thank you, sir!

  10. Dan Knauss Avatar

    I never saw the problem; seems like the right choice, but narrow focus is probably an adaptive response to protect attention, cognitive limits, and one’s craft. It’s just not what the web and the world actually need.

  11. […] ماخذ: اصل خبر دیکھیں […]

  12. Django de Montréal Avatar
    Django de Montréal

    It was the right choice, IMHO

    I embraced learning about all different aspects of the trade beyond my own craft!

  13. dusoft Avatar

    The broader spectrum of articles and more topics were good decisions. I agree that ALA seemed as it only sourced a very closed community of authors.

  14. […] The Day the Focus Died Jeffrey Zeldman: Focusing on CSS, semantic markup, and workarounds had made sense during the early standards advocacy period. […]

  15. Marko Bijelic Avatar

    I think we need to look at the bigger picture. Jeffrey played a crucial role in making web standards prevail, and as the saying goes, the revolution devours its own children. Once web standards won, the industry no longer needed A List Apart or the people who had fought so hard to make that revolution happen.

    I believe Jeffrey made the right decision because it was the only future that made sense for A List Apart.

    I also don’t think A List Apart could ever have become Smashing Magazine or CSS-Tricks. They were built around fundamentally different philosophies.

    Yes, some of the same authors wrote for Smashing Magazine, but neither Smashing Magazine nor CSS-Tricks ever had those iconic articles that we still remember more than twenty years later. They simply never had those defining hits that changed the way an entire industry thought about the web.

  16. Erin Lynch Avatar

    I was there. I lived this mission for 12 years, slogging through the trenches with you and everyone else. What I understand now after having built my own studio and establishing or supporting several other editorial endeavors since then, is that the strength of business decisions are often best reflected on after period of time after the decision is made (a gimme), but also when they are decoupled purely from the money aspect.

    I know we all wanted ALA to be this cutting-edge beacon of editorial wonder — an indelible font of wisdom AS WELL AS a publication that was a singular revenue giant. Did both of those things happen? No, but to me, the more important one did happen. ALA is and was a font of wisdom, a trailblazer that gave way to the other magazines mentioned in this post. It has earned its place in the annals of web design history. 100 percent. And in that way, perhaps philosophically the most important way, that makes it a brilliant business decision on your part.

    I would not trade my time with ALA for anything. I was in the thick of the nascent, burgeoning web during the heart of the web standards fight — a fight that was won btw, solidifying your business decisions as worthy and well executed. I would not be the designer (graphic, ux, web, etc.) if it had not been for your passion AND those biz decisions that were being made in the thick of an industry that has never suffered fools.

  17. Hypertexthero Avatar
    Hypertexthero

    I learned lots from ALA (thank you!) and the “change of focus” didn’t really bother me, but I always had misgivings about the word “apart” in the name, in the same way I now regret the word “hero” in my online name.

  18. […] The Day the Focus Died Jeffrey Zeldman: Focusing on CSS, semantic markup, and workarounds had made sense during the early standards advocacy period. […]

Got something to say?

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.